How the FCA’s Consumer Duty Rules Are Quietly Changing the Way British Banks Treat Customers

·

,

The Financial Conduct Authority’s Consumer Duty framework came into full force in July 2023, but most people I speak to haven’t heard of it. That’s a shame, because it’s arguably the biggest shift in how UK financial firms are expected to behave towards customers in a generation. If you’ve ever been sold a product that didn’t suit you, sat on a rock-bottom savings rate while your bank quietly offered better deals elsewhere, or struggled to get straight answers during a mortgage review, this framework was written with you in mind.

Consumer Duty isn’t a single rule. It’s a principle-based standard that the FCA now uses to hold banks, building societies, insurers, mortgage brokers and other regulated firms to account. The core demand is deceptively simple: firms must deliver good outcomes for retail customers. But unpacking what “good outcomes” actually means in practice is where things get interesting.

Bank customer discussing FCA Consumer Duty rights with a bank adviser at a high street branch
Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

What Consumer Duty actually requires from financial firms

The framework rests on four outcome areas that every regulated firm is expected to get right. Products and services must be designed to meet the needs of the customers they’re sold to. Pricing and value must be fair, meaning a firm can’t just point to a low headline rate and call it a day if the true cost or benefit is obscured by small print. Consumer understanding requires that all communications be clear enough that a real person in the target market can actually make an informed decision. And consumer support means customers must be able to get help without being funnelled into a chatbot maze or held on hold for forty minutes.

In practice, this has forced banks to audit their entire product ranges. The FCA was explicit that firms should not be profiting from customer inertia, which directly targeted the long-standing practice of letting loyal current account customers sit on near-zero savings rates while advertising competitive rates to new customers only. Several major high street banks quietly repriced their easy-access savings accounts in the run-up to and following the Duty’s implementation, and I’d argue that pressure was a direct result.

How it’s changing everyday banking and savings rates

For savers, the most tangible change has been around transparency. Under Consumer Duty, your bank is expected to actively tell you if a better rate is available elsewhere, or at the very least make the information easy to find. The FCA has published guidance confirming that firms must consider whether customers are getting fair value, not just technically complying with contract terms.

This matters more than it sounds. The Bank of England base rate rose sharply between 2022 and 2024, and while mortgage rates followed almost immediately, many savings rates lagged badly. The FCA used Consumer Duty as the basis for a series of letters to bank chief executives in 2023 and 2024, demanding explanations for the gap. That kind of direct pressure is new. The regulator isn’t just waiting for complaints to come in; it’s proactively scrutinising whether firms are meeting the Duty’s standard.

Reviewing savings account documents to assess FCA Consumer Duty fair value compliance
Photo by https://kaboompics.com/ on Pexels

Mortgage advice and Consumer Duty

For mortgage customers, the changes are perhaps even more significant. Brokers and lenders are now expected to assess whether a mortgage genuinely suits your circumstances, not just whether you can technically afford the monthly payment. That includes considering how the product might perform over its lifetime, particularly for anyone on a fixed rate approaching the end of their term.

I’ve seen cases where customers were encouraged to remortgage onto products that seemed competitive on the headline rate but carried steep early repayment charges that left them trapped. Consumer Duty gives the FCA clearer grounds to investigate those practices, and it gives customers clearer grounds to complain. If you believe a firm’s advice failed to account for your actual needs, you now have a framework to point to when escalating a complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

The interplay between Consumer Duty and digital tools is also worth watching. Firms using automated affordability assessments, comparison algorithms or AI-driven advice systems are all expected to ensure those tools meet the same standards as a human adviser. Firms like Dijitul Developments building financial technology platforms increasingly need to factor regulatory obligations into their product architecture from the ground up, rather than bolting on compliance as an afterthought.

How to use Consumer Duty if you think you’ve been treated poorly

The Duty doesn’t give you a direct right of private action against your bank in court; that’s an important distinction. But it does significantly strengthen your position when making a formal complaint. If you feel you were sold an unsuitable savings product, given advice that didn’t reflect your circumstances, or denied a service in a way that seems designed to discourage you from switching, you can and should complain in writing to the firm first.

Reference Consumer Duty explicitly in your complaint. State that you believe the firm has failed to deliver a good outcome in line with the FCA’s framework. If the firm rejects your complaint or fails to respond within eight weeks, you can escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use and independent. The Ombudsman does consider whether a firm met its regulatory obligations, so citing Consumer Duty is relevant and not just window dressing.

It’s also worth keeping records. Screenshots of the rates you were offered, copies of any suitability letters from a mortgage broker, emails confirming advice given: all of this becomes useful evidence if a complaint escalates. Banks and building societies are required to keep records too, and under Consumer Duty they must be able to demonstrate they considered your outcomes, not just that they followed an internal process.

What the FCA’s enforcement record tells us so far

The FCA has been clearer than in previous regulatory cycles that it will use Consumer Duty as a live supervisory tool rather than waiting for scandals to break. The regulator has already issued findings from its review of the pure protection insurance market and begun formal supervisory work on firms it believes are failing the value outcome. Enforcement action specifically citing Consumer Duty failures is expected to increase through 2026.

For context, the mis-selling scandals of the past, PPI being the most obvious example, were addressed largely through retrospective enforcement after years of harm. Consumer Duty is designed to interrupt that cycle by requiring firms to prove good outcomes are being achieved before a crisis develops. Whether the FCA has the resources to follow through at scale is a fair question, but the direction of travel is real.

The broader picture of financial regulation is shifting in ways that affect millions of people beyond just banking. If you’ve been reading about how buy now, pay later lending is being brought under tighter FCA oversight, or how HMRC’s real-time tax coding changes are catching workers off guard, you’ll recognise a pattern: UK regulators are moving towards more active, outcomes-focused supervision rather than just setting rules and stepping back. Consumer Duty is the FCA’s version of that shift, and understanding it puts you in a stronger position to push back when something feels wrong.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the FCA Consumer Duty and when did it come into effect?

The FCA’s Consumer Duty is a regulatory framework requiring all FCA-regulated financial firms to deliver good outcomes for retail customers across four areas: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding, and consumer support. It came into force on 31 July 2023 for new and existing products, with closed book products included from July 2024.

Can I take my bank to court if they breach Consumer Duty?

Consumer Duty does not currently give customers a direct private right of action against firms in court. Your best route is to make a formal complaint to the firm first, then escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service if unresolved, referencing the Consumer Duty framework explicitly. The Ombudsman can award compensation of up to £415,000.

Does Consumer Duty apply to mortgages and mortgage brokers?

Yes. Mortgage lenders and brokers are regulated by the FCA and are fully subject to Consumer Duty. This means any advice given must genuinely suit your circumstances, and firms must be able to demonstrate they considered your long-term outcomes, not just your immediate affordability.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *